https://kit.com/EEVblog/soldering-equipment Logged The following users thanked this post: saturation, SeanB, boffin, Asuka ulwur Contributor So, which one is better? We also appreciated the fun blue and yellow color combination. But its handle got uncomfortably warm in our tests, and its included stand is unstable. Anyways, I am not sure the FX-8801 and similar soldering irons are very effective transferring heat to the tip. Weller user for many years. Hakko FX888D-23BY vs Weller WE1010NA stations, is one significantly better than the other? #3. How easy is it to use Hakko and Weller soldering stations? The Weller WE1010NA has an LCD display that is simple to read. Apologies if y'all get this question a lot. Includes one (1) We1 station with 120V power, one (1) Wep70 tip retainer, one (1) Wep70 iron, one (1) PH70 safety rest with sponge, and one (1) Eta tip screwdriver measuring 0.062 inches/1.6 millimeters. I haven't been doing much PCB work lately, was still motorcycle time. People also use soldering irons for jewelry metalwork, though this guide focuses on electronics use. This is especially useful for working on small components or soldering in hard-to-reach places. Still, Wellers stand has a nice tips storage that can keep four tips organized and within reach. Soldering irons are mainly used for light and medium duty work, such as soldering electronic components to PCBs. There are many different soldering stations on the market, but two of the most popular ones are Hakko and Weller. The filler metal has a lower melting point than the workpieces being joined, so it can be melted without damaging them. weller we1010 vs hakko fx888d vs sequre sq-001 : soldering - Reddit No matter if youre a beginner or a seasoned professional, you want a soldering station that is easy to set up and use. This is when the temperature of your soldering iron drops after you've turned it on. Soldering mats come in a variety of sizes, but we recommend getting one thats at least 12x16. Weller WE1010NA Digital Soldering Station Review. However, it came with a nicely sized conical tip and held its temperature during testing. Both the Weller WE1010NA and the Hakko FX888D have some amazing features in common, like 3 push buttons for simple temperature adjustment, a 70-watt power output, and many more. It is lightweight, adaptable, ESD-safe, and can hold a variety of various tips. Hot air workstations are best suited for people who are professionals or who do a lot of soldering and know how to use the appliance. Hot air workstations come with a heat gun specifically for SMDs (surface-mount devices), which are small electronic components that are soldered to the surface of a PCB. The power unit provides power to the system, while the control unit regulates the temperature of the soldering tips. I have the Weller. The FX-888D also comes with a carrying case and an instruction manual. Becky Stern, Instructables content creator and teacher, email interview, Caleb Kraft, Make magazine senior editor, email interview, John Edgar Park, Adafruit Industries maker and content creator, email interview, Sini Saja, How to Pick the Best Soldering Iron, Instructables, The Best Soldering Irons, BestReviews, January 25, 2016, Nate Seidle, Beginning Embedded Electronics, SparkFun, June 19, 2008, Bill Earl, Adafruit Guide To Excellent Soldering, Adafruit, May 4, 2015, Joel_E_B, How to Solder: Through-Hole Soldering, SparkFun, September 19, 2013. It also had one of the slowest heating times. It supplies heat to melt the solder so that it can flow into the joint between two workpieces. Doh! The popular Hakko FX-600 got a bit warm during soldering, felt less comfortable to hold due to a lack of padding, and doesnt come with a stand or accessories. For example, some soldering systems allow you to connect soldering iron and hot twizzlers to the same power unit and control the temperature of both instruments with a single controller. The device is slightly heavy but easy to use. Back in the days when I used a soldering iron every day to earn a living, I had Weller soldering stations. [2], [3], [4]. Buying my first "nice" soldering station Hakko or Weller? So, the Hakko station is faster to heat up than the Weller. This means that most casual hobbyists dont need a fancy soldering iron, either. It is not my intention to take sides, or worse, try to be a fanboy of either. As said above, cleaning and tinning the tip has saved mine for at least a year. The Weller WE1010NA provides you with the opportunity for the iron to heat up significantly more faster, while also providing you with a much faster recovery time as well, not to mention it allows for more stable heat for circuit board repairs. EEVblog #1063 - Weller WE1010 vs Hakko FX888D Soldering Station on: March 09, 2018, 08:37:32 pm Review of two $100 class soldering stations. Hakko FX-888D Overview The Hakko FX-888D is a top-of-the-line soldering station that is perfect for professionals and amateurs alike. We have recommendations for just about every budget. By applying heat and solder, you can fuse together conductive metal elements (such as wires) to create durable, permanent connections. But its not as advanced as Hakkos. Its molded-metal-and-plastic soldering station and stand feel heavier and more durable than the other options we tested. This is perfect for those who are just starting out with soldering, as it can be difficult to hold onto tiny parts with your hands. The tip of the soldering iron gets very hot but the temperature range is lower than that of a soldering gun. Looks like I have some testing to do on it first. The Hakko FX-888D may be worth the upgrade if you plan to solder frequently, as it heats up slightly faster than the X-Tronic, so you can solder with fewer pauses. They are very flexible and easy to manipulate, which makes them well-suited for detailed work. These systems tend to have precise temperature control, quick-heating irons, and rugged designs. The included stand is just a Y-shaped piece of metal that keeps the irons tip off the table. So, the WE1010 does not seem like a meaningful upgrade over my WESD51. Overall, the Hakko soldering station is not as user-friendly as the Weller, but its still a decent choice. Be aware that you should take safety precautions anytime you work with solder.1 Work in a well-ventilated area and wash your hands thoroughly with soap after soldering. Learn more. In North America, the outlets for 110v, 220v, and 240v are completely different and cannot be accidentally plugged in. During our second round of testing, the 70-watt FX-888D reached 700 F in 35 seconds, faster than the X-Tronic but not remarkably so; any iron that took less than a minute felt fast enough to us. This can be particularly helpful when working on circuit boards as it prevents the possibility of accidentally shorting out any components.if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[320,50],'electronicshacks_com-banner-1','ezslot_18',109,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-electronicshacks_com-banner-1-0'); Some stations also come with a tip cleaner which can be very helpful for keeping the tip of the iron clean and free from build-up. A place for solderers from around the world, to gather, help one another, and hang out. A soldering iron is an essential tool for creating, modifying, or repairing electronics. Soldering Station Showdown! Hakko FX-888D vs Weller WE1010 Digital The Hakko station comes with a solid and sturdy stand that does all of these things. Helping hand is essentially an alligator clip on a stand that can be adjusted to position the workpiece in just the right spot. Weller WE1010NA vs Hakko FX888D Best Digital Soldering. We also consulted a number of experts who routinely work with students and amateurs learning to solder for the first time. Wirecutter is the product recommendation service from The New York Times. Reddit, Inc. 2023. We focused on adjustable pencils and entry-level stations for this guide because theyre the most affordable and straightforward. Solder it, please. Theres an up and down arrow key that allows you to quickly adjust the temperature. This adjustable model is the cheapest iron we tested, but it performs well and comes with more accessories than any other, including solder and multiple tip sizes. Buy several sizes of the chisel tips. But during our testing, we found that stands needed some heft to prevent them from sliding when we set down a hot soldering iron. The Weller WE1010NA is a popular entry-level soldering station that sells for around $100. You asked for it so get ready! Hakko also manufactures other tools used in electronics assembly and repair, such as tweezers, pliers, and cutters. Not using the Weller station however they are much like Fluke and build an awesome product. Your email address will not be published. A hot air workstation, also known as a reflow oven, is used for soldering electronic components to a PCB. madires. I watched a vid comparing the Weller WE1010NA to the Hakko FX888D. Soldering Station Showdown! Hakko FX-888D vs Weller WE1010 Digital Weller soldering stations are used to heat the metals being joined, as well as the solder itself. The Hakko FX-888D is rated best in class for power and performance, outperforming the competition. That could be an important feature if youre a frequent solderer. Whats more, the company has a strong focus on quality control, so you can be sure that youre getting a well-made product. Both the stand and station are heavy with grippy feet that hold them firmly in place, and they are made of molded plastic and metal with well-placed spots for a sponge and cleaning wire. In electronics, soldering is the process of joining two or more pieces of metal together by melting and flowing a filler metal (solder) onto the joint. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Looking at the Weller WE1010NA soldering station. Overall, we can see that the Hakko FX-888D is a better performing soldering station than the Weller WE1010NA. I keep a spare heater element and a spare hand piece. The Weller is a bit easier to use than the Hakko with its three-button control panel. The Delcast WST-2 is the heaviest stand weve tested at 21.2 ounces, but we found the 16.8-ounce FH-300 to also be heavy enough to tolerate our manhandling. The reliable X-Tronic heats up fast and offers a safe and sturdy stand, an ergonomic grip, and a digital temperature displayfeatures you usually have to pay twice as much to get. An ergonomic, lightweight handpiece that enhances comfort and movement. It performed okay on the Larson Scanner Kit but didnt stand out against other models. Im Wirecutters expert on technology for makers and hobbyists. Soldering systems are available in a variety of sizes and configurations, so you can find one that suits your needs. These stations come in a variety of shapes and sizes, but all include a heating element and a tip that can be swapped out depending on the project at hand. This is when the temperature of your soldering iron drops after youve turned it on. I want to repeat, the Hakko is a good station and is very pleasant to work with and will do many jobs quite well. The process of soldering with a hot air workstation is called reflow soldering. The stand has a spring holder which makes it wobble a bit when you set the soldering iron in it. Which soldering station offers the best bang for your buck? If you only do occasional soldering then a regular iron will suffice. The X-Tronic allows control down to the degree and offers peace of mind, as you wont fry your project with a too-hot iron. This is generally located at the front of the station for easy access. Soldering guns are not as precise as other types of soldering irons, so they are not ideal for delicate work. A soldering mat is one of those must-have accessories for any soldering station. The station also gives you the option to set passwords if multiple people are using it. Lets compare their two models, The Weller WE1010NA and Hakkos FX-888D. For more information, please see our Hakko FX888D debuted in 2011 and Weller WE1010NA in 2017. Although the X-Tronics maximum temperature was average in our tests, that max863 Fis plenty hot for most basic projects. The Velleman VTSS5U had the longest heat-up time (7 minutes 25 seconds) and a low maximum temperature. The Hakko FX-888D is our top pick because its more versatile and packed with more accessories than the Weller WE1010NA. The Hakkos stand is actually very easy to take apart. Now lets take a closer look at the temperature range. We liked a lot about it during our testingit was the most comfortable model and the fastest to heat up at 28 seconds. In addition, solder typically has a much lower tensile strength than the materials being joined. When you are looking into purchasing a new soldering station, you need to make sure that you consideration the size of the area that you are planning on working in, who is going to be around when you are working (again, the Hakko offers a passcode feature which prevents unwanted users, including children, from using it when you are not around, it also locks the temperature so that it cant be changed), and also what exactly it is that you are looking to get out of your soldering station as well, as you will want to make sure the the heat range is going to work for your personal and/or professional needs all-in-all. Its also the smallest of any of the stands we tested, which leaves more room in your work space for other soldering bits and bobs. While theres many solder options out there, we recommend using rosin core solder for your soldering station. 0 Ratings ON AMAZON Weller WE1010NA vs Hakko FX888D: The Weller WE1010NA and Hakko FX888D are both great options for digital soldering stations, but which one is the best? I've never seen one. https://www.weller-tools.com/profesines/WT+Line/Soldering+stations+and+sets/WT1H. Soldering is distinguished from brazing in that the temperatures used and the metals involved are different. We spoke with Becky Stern, a content creator and teacher with Instructables and former director of wearable electronics at Adafruit Industries; Caleb Kraft, senior editor of Make magazine; and John Edgar Park of Adafruit Industries. shipping Sale Top #2 Hakko FX601-02 Adjustable Temperature Controlled Soldering Iron, 67 Watts I'm waiting for a mx-5000 to show up for a good price. Graph of thermal recovery Continuous work results in a rise time to 350 degrees Celsius that is 20 seconds faster and a slower temperature drop at the tip. The ones with Teflon insulation work for soldering iron tip measurements but the lower temperature ones work fine also even though their insulation near the tip eventually scorches. The full guide:https://core-electronics.com.au/tutorials/soldering-showdown-hakko-vs-weller.htmlRelated tutorial, Soldering 101: https://core-electronics.com.au/tutorials/soldering-101.html Core Electronics is located in the heart of Newcastle, Australia. The FX-888D is incredibly easy to use with a digital readout and interface requiring only two buttons for usage. This is usually done in order to keep costs down. Its important because you dont want your soldering iron to cool down too much in between uses, as this can make soldering more difficult. Per the title - looking at a Hakko FX-888, and a Weller WE1010. This will further extend the life of your soldering station. Its the least expensive iron we tested, it performed well in our tests, and it comes with the most accessories (though not all of them are useful or well designed). The right tools make all the difference. And that in and of itself is something that you should make number one on your list of considerations. If youre looking for the cheapest decent soldering iron, our budget pick is the best option. Wellers product line includes both entry-level and professional-grade soldering irons and stations. Again, its important to note that soldering stations are pretty pricey. What makes soldering stations different from other soldering appliances is that they come with a stand. Chisel tips have a wide, flat surface that is good for soldering larger surfaces. Weller also shines in the control department. In addition to that, Hakkos stand offers two ways to clean the soldering iron tip. Still, its important to be careful when using one and to avoid touching the hot tip. Ive spent the past eight years writing about makers and engineers, plus topics such as robots and 3D printers. However, the WE1010NA doesnt fall behind in this category. Model: Hakko FX888D-23BY: Hakko FX888D-23BY-Kit4: Hakko FX888D-29BY: Weller WE1010NA: Product: STATION, SDRG, DIGITAL, ESD, FX-8801, FX-888D: Digital Soldering Station ESD Safe version with 4 extra tips - T18-B/D08/D12/D24 tips: We dont think its an issue for general electronics work, but you should consider looking into what temperatures you will need your iron to reach for other types of projects. So, if I'm ready for a better iron and I'm willing to go up to, say $500, what's the best iron I can get at that price? 11 Best Soldering Stations - Our Picks, Alternatives & Reviews I use the ETA 1/16 inch tip "chisel or screwdriver tip. The X-Tronic Model 3020-XTS LED Soldering Station offers the best experience for beginners and hobbyists who want to jump right into working with electronics kits. The 75-watt X-Tronic iron heated to 700 F (a reasonable temperature for working with electronics) in 47 seconds. The 6.5-ounce Elenco WeMake Soldering Iron Stand is cheap, but its so light that it has a tendency to skate around a work surface if youre not gentle about replacing the soldering iron. We once recommended an older Delcast model, the SL-WST, but it has a longer and clumsier setup process than the FH-300 and the largest footprint of any stand weve tested. The WE1010 tip immediately liquifies existing solder and allows driving it along a seam. The Vastars grip got the warmest among the irons we tested, and the temperatures marked on the Vastars adjustment wheel proved to be totally inaccurate, as well. Keep children and pets away from the area where you solder. Soldering is easy enough that you can learn the basics in a few minutes. Weller WE1010 vs Hakko FX888D Soldering Station - EEVblog The 3020-XTS comes with a thin blue sponge for wiping the irons tip, and its the only soldering set in our test group that includes a brass sponge for cleaning the tip, as well. There are plenty of appliances you can use for soldering. I have that same Hakko which is my first "real" soldering iron. Other models I testedincluding the Atten SA-50, the Hakko FX-600, the Vastar Full Set 60W 110V Soldering Iron Kit, and the Velleman VTSS5Uwere warm enough at the base to force me to shift my grip higher up, and as a result they were less comfortable, harder to use, and less safe-feeling. Thanks for reading and happy soldering! 3 wellers here built hundreds of boards, use them daily. How well do Hakko and Weller soldering stations work? However, one downside is that they take longer to heat up than other types of soldering appliances. TOP 10 Hakko Vs Weller TOP 10 Hakko Vs Weller Top 10 Reviews / By Amy Wang For Amazon Sellers - Contact Us Here. http://www.hakko.com/english/company/profile/outline.html . It can also be used for joining metals such as copper, brass, and aluminum.if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'electronicshacks_com-medrectangle-4','ezslot_11',107,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-electronicshacks_com-medrectangle-4-0'); There are two main types of soldering: soft soldering and hard soldering. In this comparative research, we'll examine and contrast the Weller WE1010NA and Hakko FX888D products to see which one is the best. It is important to be careful when using these tools, and always keep them away from children. This gives them an edge over stations with analog controls that can be more difficult to use. Anyways, in this light, the WE1010 exhibits a more realistic and honest warmup response. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. A helping hand is a useful tool that will hold your workpiece in place while youre soldering. [2]. Sadly, in spite of Daves video, the WE1010 outperforms the Hakko on FR4 ground plane soldering. In our tests, the Aoyue 469 tied with the Weller WE1010NA as the most comfortable iron to hold, and it came with a nice collection of accessories, but it had the longest setup time at nearly 10 minutes and one of the lowest maximum temperatures. I use a pair of the WD models since they use the 80 watt hand-pieces. comes with a thin, comfortable handpiece that is ideal for any soldering project. [2], [3], [4]. Hakko uses its own proprietary tips which can only be used with their irons. Soldering can be a tricky task, so having a helping hand to hold your workpieces can be a lifesaver! This through-hole kit includes a microcontroller, a battery holder, and nine LEDs that you must solder to a circuit board. The latest version of the iron, which we have yet to test, comes with a set of helping handsclips that hold a circuit board in place while you work. Digital vs. Analog Signal: Whats the Difference? However, certain products may be outsourced to other countries, such as China. A circular neat sleeve, however makes it worse. It only indicates, that the heater core warms up very quickly to the setpoint. The Weller is super well built and made-up of the highest quality, it also takes up very minimal space on the workbench, which is perfect if you are short on space. *At the time of publishing, the price was $32. Soldering stations come in two parts: a base (typically with a holster, a temperature dial, and a sponge) and an iron that plugs into the base. Always unplug the soldering iron when youre not using it and be sure to allow it to cool down before storing it.if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'electronicshacks_com-leader-2','ezslot_15',113,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-electronicshacks_com-leader-2-0'); The size and shape of the tip is another important consideration. Weller tips will simply be too small to fit snugly on a Hakko iron. Where ?? It is also one of the few irons we tested with a digital displaya feature that makes tracking and changing the temperature especially easy. As was the case with the Model 3020-XTS, it always stayed cool to the touch. Weller is still a good station, we just feel that Hakko offers more bang for your buck. To calibrate it I just found out the melting temp of solder and slowly brought it up until it started to melt. EEVblog #1063 - Weller WE1010 vs Hakko FX888D Soldering Station EEVblog 900K subscribers Join Subscribe 4.7K Share Save 249K views 4 years ago Review of two $100 class soldering stations.. The Weller WE1010 has dimensions of 5.91 x 8.86 x 12.4 inches and a weight of 5.51 pounds. We recommend the Hakko FH-300. The X-Tronic was the cheapest station we tested thats equipped with a digital temperature display; the Weller WE1010NA and Hakko FX-888D are the only other irons we tested that have displays. Unfortunately, theres just two of them. Specifications The weight is 2.6 pounds; The dimensions are 9.6 x 9.6 x 7.3 inches; The voltage is 120 Volts; The wattage is 70 Watts; The standard package includes the power supply, iron holder, sponge, and waterless cleaner; Made with plastic and metal; The temperature range (adjusted) is 120 - 899F; The idle temperature is within 1.8F; The Hakko FX-888D has a temp range from 120 to 899F (50 to 480C), while the Weller WE1010NA has a range of 200 to 850F (93 454C). I like the WE1010 adjustments more, and apparently the pen itself feels nicer to hold - but the Hakko is apparently built quite a bit better, and I like the aesthetics. Soldering irons also wont provide as much power as some of the other options.if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[320,50],'electronicshacks_com-large-mobile-banner-1','ezslot_0',114,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-electronicshacks_com-large-mobile-banner-1-0'); A soldering system is similar to a soldering station, but it allows you to connect multiple soldering instruments to a single power source. But this is only part of the story. Considering that the experts we interviewed said they stuck with their first soldering iron for years, we think its worthwhile to invest in the right one at the beginning instead of starting with a less-capable model just because its a bit less expensive. Buying my first "nice" soldering station Hakko or Weller? Like all of the irons we tested except for the Vastar, the X-Tronic soldering iron came with only a single conical tip, but it was thin enough to work well with the Larson Scanner Kit. The first thing well look at is performance. The Weller WE1010 Digital offers greater ergonomics when it comes to interface controls and the soldering pencil. The FX-888D is a digital soldering station that comes with a temperature control unit, a power unit, and a soldering iron. As with the other irons we tested, the X-Tronic models temperature dipped a few times during use due to the heat dissipating while we were soldering, and we had to wait for it to get hot enough again to melt solder. Hakko FX888D-23BY vs Weller WE1010NA stations, is one - Reddit One aspect, that clearly came to light, comparing some of the results from Daves video is, that the fast apparent warmup time compared to the WE1010 is not terribly meaningful at all. Plus, the fact that the stand and station are two separate pieces gives you more flexibility in how you set up your work zone. We use cookies to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. Otherwise they're pretty much identical in features. We did find that it heated up quickly, held its temperature well, and produced one of the highest maximum temperatures. This means that the Hakko soldering station will maintain a more consistent temperature, making it easier to use. Yes, Weller is a good soldering brand. The Hakko is also slightly larger in size, but not too tremendously so in terms of taking up too much space overall. If you dont have enough space, it can be difficult to use the soldering station and you may find yourself constantly moving things around. If you want a top-of-the-line model with all the bells and whistles then you can expect to pay over $200. TiA. Answer: ness electronics is mentioned as a retailer on the HakkoUSA website (under "where to buy"). This can be useful if you have multiple solderers working in the same area, as it reduces the risk of tripping over cords. Sadly i'm not realy impressed by both solderingstations. We also skipped cordless irons, which are useful for their portability but require trade-offs that arent worth making for beginners: They heat up more slowly, consume batteries quickly, and can damage delicate electronics. Weller WE1010NA vs Hakko FX888D. While putting together our electronics-project kit, we occasionally had to wait for the X-Tronic soldering station to rebound to its set temperature; you could spend around $40 more for an iron with a faster temperature rebound, but we barely noticed the difference. I would recommend it to anyone. Learn more from our comparison. Here, we will be examining two of the top-rated ones that you may just want to take into consideration. We measured the temperature at each marker on their control knobs, as well. Quote from: LektroiD on 08 Jun, 2018 11:08, Powered by SMFPacks Advanced Attachments Uploader Mod. Hakko publishes a page of retail stores and authorized partners that stock its products. Although it wasnt calibratedits measurements appeared to be consistently higher than the temperature stated on the soldering irons gaugesit allowed us to make a consistent comparison across the irons we tested. This 16.8-ounce model stayed in place during our testing, unlike the 6.5-ounce Elenco WeMake Soldering Iron Stand.
Ideal House Round Coffee Table, Soundbar With Battery Rear Speakers, Articles H